TradeStation vs Yellow Card: Fees, Security, Features & Which to Choose (2025)

Trying to choose between TradeStation and Yellow Card This side-by-side comparison reveals total cost (fees + spreads), security & licenses, coins/derivatives, deposits/withdrawals, and app quality. In 2 minutes you’ll see who wins for beginners, active traders, and long-term holders. Clear pros/cons, a quick verdict, and safe links to get started.

Last updated on August 23, 2025

TradeStation

Yellow Card

⚠️ We look for what’s best for you.

₿ Getting into crypto? With eToro you can start in minutes: buy/sell top coins, set recurring buys, track markets, and use Social/CopyTrader features.

👉 Start here and explore the crypto offer.

Available Countries

United States

Yes

Europe

Latin America

India

China

Canada

United Kingdom

United States

Europe

Latin America

India

China

Canada

United Kingdom

Thinking about starting with crypto? This is for you.

In select regions, eToro offers a $10 welcome bonus when you open an account today.*

🎯 An account built to help you start with crypto—without the hassle.

➕ Buy and sell top cryptocurrencies in minutes

➕ Recurring buys, price alerts, and advanced charts

➕ Social/CopyTrader™ to follow experienced investors

➕ One of the largest and most trusted platforms worldwide

Limited-time promotion — still available.

*Offer subject to terms, eligibility and regional availability. Don’t invest unless you’re prepared to lose all the money you invest.

TradeStation is ideal if:

Yellow Card is ideal if:

Ideal if you prioritize local African access – it supports fiat on-ramps and local payment methods like mobile money, cash agents, and bank transfers across many African markets.
Perfect for simplicity and security – the user-friendly interface, strong AML/KYC processes, and embedded compliance make it approachable and trustworthy for new users.
Great for businesses needing robust infrastructure – with tools like embedded widgets, a Payments API, and invoice settlement, it's tailored for seamless crypto-fiat integration in emerging markets.

TradeStation isn’t ideal if:

Yellow Card isn’t ideal if:

Not for variety seekers – the platform offers a narrow range of cryptocurrencies, making it unsuitable if you want exposure to many or newer digital assets.
Limited advanced tools – lacking features like futures, staking, or analytic dashboards, it’s less suited if you're into sophisticated trading strategies.
Not ideal for non-African users – it’s built around African markets and local payment methods, so those outside this region may find it inconvenient or inaccessible.

Fees & Total Costs

Spot Maker/Take

TradeStation’s crypto spot offering has been discontinued, so volume-based maker/taker pricing and any native token discounts are no longer applicable.

Yellow Card does not use traditional maker or taker fees—instead, it applies a modest spread on spot trades, keeping the user experience simple without volume-based tiers or discounts tied to any native token.

Futures/Derivatives

Futures on TradeStation feature flat, per-contract maker/taker charges (e.g. Bitcoin futures around $7.50 per side) plus additional pass-through exchange and regulatory fees, with no separate funding rate structure since perpetual contracts aren’t available.

Yellow Card doesn’t offer futures or derivative trading, so there are no associated maker/taker fees, funding charges, or leverage costs to consider.

Average Spreads on Liquid Pairs

TradeStation’s model did not include embedded spreads on spot crypto—prices were transparent and routed through liquidity sources—but with its exit from spot services, spread data is no longer relevant.

The platform’s spread-based model keeps spreads consistently small for popular pairs, designed for clarity and predictability rather than frequent fluctuations tied to liquidity.

Fiat Deposits & Withdrawals

You cannot deposit or withdraw fiat directly into a crypto account; instead, you need an equities account to convert fiat into crypto, and TradeStation does not charge specific crypto deposit or withdrawal fees.

You can fund your account using bank transfers, mobile money, or cash-agents—with service fees that vary by channel (typically around 1–2%) and settlement times ranging from near-instant (in local mobile networks) to same-day for bank transfers.

On-chain Withdrawals

TradeStation historically offered crypto withdrawals without explicit fees set by them—but since spot services are no longer supported, on-chain withdrawal fee structures are not currently relevant.

Transfers on alt-chains like Polygon or Solana are free, while ERC-20 and TRC-20 stablecoin withdrawals carry a modest flat fee (about 1.5 USDT), and crypto withdrawals like BTC or ETH incur standard miner fees that adjust with network congestion.

Hidden Costs

TradeStation was transparent with zero hidden fees for custody, deposits, or withdrawals on crypto; however, general account charges—like currency conversion fees if funding in non-USD, or inactivity fees—may apply through corresponding services.

There are no obscure charges like inactivity or express KYC fees; costs are transparent and tied to the payment method or network chosen, with currency conversions integrated into the pricing or spread rather than applied as additional hidden fees.

Real-World Cost Example: “€500 BTC

Since TradeStation no longer provides spot crypto trading, this kind of transaction flow—comprising commission, spread, and withdrawal—is not feasible to illustrate in today’s context.

If you purchase €500 worth of BTC, your cost combines a small spread on the BTC price plus a service fee for converting your fiat (around 1–2%), and if you withdraw on-chain, a standard network fee applies—altogether designed to stay straightforward and avoid unexpected charges.

Crypto Offering & Trading Features

Number of Coins & Pairs

TradeStation Crypto supports around 11 digital assets, covering core coins like Bitcoin, Ethereum, Litecoin, USD Coin, and a few others; full pair listings are limited and none extend beyond the most liquid top-20 names.

Yellow Card supports a limited selection of core assets—Bitcoin (BTC), Ethereum (ETH), Tether (USDT), Cardano (ADA), Solana (SOL), USD Coin (USDC), Polygon (MATIC), Celo Dollar (cUSD), Tether Gold (XAUt), and PayPal USD (PYUSD)—but does not provide a wide array of trading pairs or a ranked list by volume.

Product Range

TradeStation offers spot crypto trading and regulated crypto futures (e.g. XRP futures via CME) but does not provide margin, perpetual contracts, options on crypto, crypto ETFs, staking or earn programs, loans, copy trading, grid bots, or automatic DCA features.

The platform specializes solely in spot buying and selling; it does not offer margin, perpetuals, options, crypto ETFs, staking or lending programs, copy trading, grid bots, or automated DCA features.

Liquidity

TradeStation aggregates liquidity from multiple sources via its intelligent routing system, delivering solid execution quality, though specific 24-hour volumes or precise order-book depth data (for BTC/ETH) are not publicly disclosed.

While there’s basic liquidity for BTC and ETH via spot trades and commercial OTC access, the platform does not publish typical 24-hour volume or book-depth metrics, so these indicators remain undisclosed.

Tools

The platform features advanced tools such as limit, stop, bracket/OCO orders, customizable alerts, richly featured charts with extensive technical indicators, plus REST and FIX APIs for automation—but does not embed native TradingView.

Yellow Card provides simple buy/sell workflows with minimal advanced order types—no stop, limit, OCO, alert systems, in-app charts, or TradingView integration—but does offer an API and embeddable widget for businesses to integrate fiat-crypto on-ramps.

Geographic Restrictions by Product

Crypto offerings—including spot and futures—are limited to users in the United States; many advanced products like regulated crypto derivatives are not accessible to users in other regions such as Europe, Latin America, or Asia.

As derivatives and advanced trading products are not offered anywhere, there is effectively no geographic variation—only basic spot services are accessible across supported African markets.

Innovation

TradeStation does not currently offer launchpad or launchpool-style offerings, nor any flexible or locked earning programs like staking or yield products.

The platform does not feature launchpads, launchpools, or different earn modalities; its innovation focus lies in seamless cross-border payments via Stablecoins, API integrations, and improving fiat on-ramp infrastructure.

Security, Regulation & Custody

Operating Entity & Jurisdiction

TradeStation Crypto, Inc.—a subsidiary of TradeStation Group, Inc., itself owned by Monex Group—was established around 2018 and is headquartered in Plantation, Florida, operating under U.S. jurisdiction.

The parent company, Yellow Card Financial Inc., was established in Delaware in 2016 and later converted into a C-corporation, with registered offices in Delaware and Alabama; it also operates through local subsidiaries across Africa to meet regional legal and tax obligations.

Licenses/Registration

The crypto division operated under money transmitter licenses in multiple U.S. states, but lacked specific VASP or MiCA/European registrations, as it was not structured under those frameworks.

Yellow Card holds a Virtual Asset Service Provider (VASP) license from Botswana and a Crypto Asset Service Provider (CASP) license in South Africa, reflecting its commitment to working under formal regulatory frameworks in key African markets.

Custody

Crypto assets were held via a third-party custodian (BitGo), with no public proof of reserves, audit disclosures, or specified allocation percentages in cold storage.

Customer cryptocurrencies are securely held via Fireblocks infrastructure, using MPC-CMP to safeguard private keys and equipped with high-level security certifications and regular penetration testing; the platform itself does not engage in staking or borrowing with user assets.

Insurance & Protection Funds

There was no dedicated crypto insurance or indemnity fund; protections were limited to those applicable to the U.S. financial system (e.g. SIPC doesn’t cover crypto).

Yellow Card does not offer explicit insurance or dedicated protection funds for user assets; instead, its security emphasis lies on institutional-grade custody and compliance rather than insurance-based safeguards.

Incident History

TradeStation faced regulatory sanctions for its crypto yield program—including a consolidated $3m settlement with the SEC and NASAA—and a separate FINRA fine of $85k for misleading communications; no major security breaches were reported.

There are no known reports or record of hacks, platform suspensions, asset freezing, or regulatory fines associated with Yellow Card, which suggests a clean operational history to date.

Risk Controls

The platform included layered security like encrypted access, automatic logout, account change alerts, and anti-fraud monitoring systems; however, specific features like withdrawal whitelists, sub-accounts, or segmented API permission sets were not disclosed.

Security controls include mandatory multi-factor authentication with options like 2FA and OTP, strong internal training and encryption protocols, real-time threat monitoring with auto-lock features, and robust anti-phishing guidance embedded in the platform experience.

Transparency

There were no publicly available monthly cryptocurrency reports, wallet visibility, or formal SLAs related to crypto; financial safety was presented via reserve disclosures for futures accounts under CFTC rules.

While Yellow Card offers secure embedded infrastructure and compliance transparency, there is no indication that it publishes public monthly reports, maintains a viewable public wallet, or guarantees formal service levels (SLA) beyond its regulatory obligations.

Deposits, Withdrawals, KYC & Support

Fiat Deposit Methods

TradeStation’s crypto arm doesn’t accept fiat deposits—these must go through a TradeStation Securities equities account via ACH, wire transfer, check, or transfer service, with typical same-day to few-business-day processing depending on method and no specified minimums.

Yellow Card enables deposits via mobile money, bank transfers (manual), and cash agents, with minimum amounts varying by country and reflecting local currencies; mobile money deposits are typically instant, while manual bank transfers may take up to 48 hours to reflect.

Supported Fiat Currencies & Conversion

KYC (Verification Levels)

TradeStation requires a standard identity verification (including SSN/ITIN for U.S. users or passport/address proof for international users) during account opening; there are no tier levels publicly described, and trading access is granted post-full KYC, with no stated limitations tied to KYC levels.

Users begin at an introductory tier with basic identity information and limited functionality, with higher tiers unlocked through document and funding verification—each providing progressively higher deposit, withdrawal, and trading limits.

Withdrawals

Crypto withdrawals specify minimum amounts per asset (e.g., BTC 0.0012, ETH 0.018, USDC 50) and are processed only during U.S. business hours, with times varying by blockchain; network fees apply, but there’s no mention of support for multiple networks like TRC20 or BEP20.

Withdrawal options mirror deposit methods and differ by country; mobile money withdrawals tend to be quick, while bank transfers are slower, and on-chain crypto withdrawals use networks such as ERC-20 or TRC-20 where available, with specific limits tied to your KYC tier and jurisdiction.

Customer Support

TradeStation offers a chatbot (TSbot) and FAQ support to assist with common issues, but real-life reviews cite slow response times and occasional difficulty reaching live support; an online knowledge base is available, though 24/7 live chat support isn’t clearly offered.

Support is accessible via in-app chat 24/7 throughout the African operating regions, complemented by email assistance and a knowledge base to guide users through common issues or questions.

Languages & Localization

The platform supports multiple languages on its global site, but Spanish-language support and pricing in EUR for crypto context are not explicitly available—its main interface and fee structure are U.S.-centric, so local regulatory or tax settings may vary.

The app is localized in multiple African languages (Hausa, Swahili, Zulu, Yoruba, etc.), and displays amounts in both local fiat and USD, ensuring it fits the region’s linguistic and regulatory contexts.

App Quality & Stability

TradeStation’s mobile app supports crypto trading for iOS and Android and receives regular updates, but user feedback indicates that while generally stable for advanced users, the platform can feel overly technical and occasionally glitchy, especially for newcomers.

The core experience is delivered through native mobile apps on Android and iOS, optimized for stability and security; as of August 1, 2025, legacy access via web and older operating systems will be phased out to improve performance and maintain high reliability.

Experience, Performance & Ecosystem

UX/UI

The TradeStation interface is highly customizable and powerful, offering a learning curve that leans toward advanced users; however, it does not offer separate “Lite” or “Pro” modes—everything is accessible within the same professional-level platform.

Yellow Card offers a clean, mobile-first interface designed for quick onboarding, especially for new users in Africa, with no “Lite” or “Pro” toggles—though businesses can use a more advanced API and widget for integration, while the app remains streamlined.

Performance

TradeStation is known for its strong order execution speed, even during high volatility, thanks to multi-core optimization features—and though KYC delays can occur during major bull runs, the platform itself remains stable and responsive.

The app is optimized for fast fiat-to-crypto conversions, even during peak demand, without reported crashes or slowdowns in high-volatility periods; KYC processes are integrated into the flow to minimize manual queues, particularly benefiting active markets.

Education

TradeStation offers a rich educational ecosystem—including webinars, video tutorials, and a dedicated learning center—but it lacks a built-in crypto simulator or demo for practice, and its educational content is primarily in English rather than Spanish.

Yellow Card provides structured learning through its Academy initiative, boosted by Tether-powered financial literacy campaigns across African universities, though it does not currently offer interactive demos, simulators, or Spanish-language content.

Community

While TradeStation provides a solid online help center and support forums, it does not run official Discord or Telegram groups for community interaction, nor does it feature any active referral or ambassador programs.

A vibrant presence on platforms like social media complements their knowledge base, and they run targeted ambassador programs and referral campaigns—but there are no official community forums or Discord servers listed publicly.

Integrations

TradeStation supports powerful APIs for custom trading strategies and compatibility with trading journals and portfolio tools—but does not offer built-in integration with TradingView, external bot marketplaces, tax tools, or structured accounting features.

The platform emphasizes business integrations via its widget and Payments API for seamless fiat-crypto flows; however, it does not integrate with charting tools like TradingView, external trading bots, tax software, or accounting platforms.

Who Each One Is Best For

This platform is ideal for experienced, tech-savvy traders who want a high-performance, highly customizable trading environment—but less suitable for beginners seeking simplified interfaces, simulator tools, or Spanish-language support.

Yellow Card is ideal for individuals and businesses in Africa seeking simple, secure, and compliant fiat-to-crypto on-ramps using local payment methods—but not for users looking for advanced trading features, educational simulators, or broad third-party tooling.